"Let me state from the start that this is an outstanding image from one of the top Dog Show Photographers in the country."

Jim, I learned many years ago: "I must be happy with the quality of my work; regardless of the expectations of my clients". I do not agree the Louisville shot is an outstanding image, it may very well be from one of the top Dog Show Photographers but the image is amateur, at best. You sited all the reasons in your dialog. Your image, on the other hand, is well lite and has good detail.

It is in your best interest to do your photography to your high standards and take the opportunity to educate your clients and future clients.