I do my absolute best to shoot full frame, composed as I want the final image. That said, things don't always work out so I have no problem cropping, or even shooting a subject that is small in the frame when I don't have enough lens.

As for which version of this I prefer; that's tough. They each have their own distinct feeling.
The first reminds me of a knight chess piece, very formal, dignified and striking.
The second is much more relaxed.

If I had to pick, I'd say I give the edge to the first, because it is a little more unique.