Debbie,

Here's my two cents worth (and I do mean two cents). I am with team Don on the cloning. I like the picture and Amber's intensity.

If it were me, a little more cropping is what I would have done. The collar is there, but crop just above the black harness and then take the top of the image down just below what appears to be a knot in the second tree. About 1/2" down in the image. That would help frame it a little better.

For what it's worth,

Doug