Frustrating! Interested in the topic, took the time to read the thread, get to the end and the images have been deleted. Followed link to Tony's site (nice site, Tony) and found the three versions but which are Tony's and which are Roman's? What was learned and shared here? Should this thread then be deleted and the bandwidth relaimed for other use?

While I am sensitive to image theft and all of that, frankly, it's a low risk/low stakes situation and elevating those conerns above the lasting educational value of threads like this one seems out of balance to me. If I'm really concerned about misappropriation of an important image, I don't post it in a public forum. Instead, if I'm looking for input, I'll consult a colleague directly and privately.

All of that aside, I'm still curious about Tony's original (unanswered) question: ...is this an image of a nanny and kid on a rock, or is it more than that? Roman says it could be a real money-maker. But why? Isn't that the crux of the matter? The answer to that question is usually the best way to inform editing so the power of the captured moment is visually conveyed.

Tony, you requested 'a real honest assessment.' If you got what you were looking for here, please ignore my comments. If not, then think about it this way. This is a pretty picture (nice scenery) of two goats on a rock, looking at you. Is there some drama, a story or memorable moment? I can't see it if there is. You have come upon these two and they are now looking at you, as opposed to whatever they were doing before you appeared. I find myself wondering about that... what they were doing before they stopped to take notice of the camera.